Peanut butter feels like a normal dog food. Xylitol versions are not. Check the jar and call.
| Scenario | Xylitol (sugar-free) ingestion |
|---|---|
| Vet vs poison control vs ER | Call poison control and your vet or ER right away. Xylitol in dogs is time-sensitive even before symptoms. Poison control helps estimate risk from the label; the clinic manages blood sugar and liver support. Cats are less commonly reported with classic xylitol crisis, but still get professional advice. |
Sugar-free and keto peanut butters are the usual surprises. Regular grocery jars often do not contain xylitol — but you verify by reading, not by brand loyalty.
If the peanut butter was baked into cookies, include flour, chocolate chips, and sweeteners in the call.
If you stuffed a toy earlier and are unsure which jar you used, bring both jars to the phone call if needed. Identifying the product matters.
Wash toys after the crisis so leftover xylitol butter is not re-licked.
This is general information, not a diagnosis. Contact your vet for anything urgent or unclear.